My 2 Cents: Football Manager 2018

I’m a little bit scared and fascinated at the same time by irreversible choices. They just change the balance of situations and you have to live with them and totally change your plans to get the best outcome.
For example… does it ever happened to you to train an EFL Championship football club and accidentally take off the captain role from a very influential player to give it to the random new guy of the team? Who didn’t, right? By the way, the club was Fulham FC.

Needless to say, that choice was a huge and total disaster! The team as a whole just tormented me asking why did I relieve Tom Cairney from his role as a captain and who the hell is that Ryan Fredericks guy – yes, I know, I’m mixing east and west London and I’m going to hell for this. As if that weren’t enough, here comes the media! Sniffing the stench of my mediocrity as a manager, they start asking loads of questions, insisting for clear answers to write scoops at my expenses. This is all so realistic that I had to pick up a pillow, smash it on my face and scream.

It took me a fair amount of talking, winning matches (guessing the right tactics) and motivating players to keep the team from super-hating me and start playing again as I wanted.
It’s now clear to me: I am not managing data and reading graphs; I am training and managing a team of simulated human beings… very spoiled and behaving Richie Rich style… but still human beings!

This time, like never before, Sports Interactive is raising the bar of relationships and human behaviors inside the fascinating simulated world of Football Manager. In fact, in this iteration of the award winning sport simulator there is a new feature: Dynamics system.

Dressing Rooms’ Dynamics

Dynamic system is probably the most exciting thing you can find in FM18. Your team is not anymore an array of data. Every single player has interests, preferences, desires, likings, dislikings and bad habits. Some wants to play a certain role, some others want to earn more money; some want their training to be harder, some like it soft, and so on. Your role is not anymore to just set training at “balanced” level, guess the right tactic and win game. To succeed in FM18, you have to have the ability to keep your team united and happy by trying to give the players what they want and interact with them in the best way since every player has his own aspirations and personality. Oh, and you also have to say the right things to the media… cause your players are watching. Always.

Dynamics system comes with a dedicated tab on the menu at the left-hand side of the screen. Here you can find all the information needed to read and understand your team behaviors and needs. You will be presented some nice graphics that shows you important statistics like match cohesion, dressing room atmosphere and managerial support and under that, you have all the reasons why the players are unhappy and unwilling to play together and also the reasons why they haven’t killed you yet with a butcher knife while you’re sleeping. In my case, the problem was just that Tom Cairney was a very influential player and I made him unhappy by stripping him of the capitancy, so I’m guessing the rest of the team was mad at me because Tom was speaking ill of me with the team behind my back? So mature of you, Tom. Really. This is why you’re not captain anymore! *pillow screaming*

Miles Jacobson in an interview with PC Gamers’ writer Joe Donnelly, explained that Dynamics system is not just changing how the players reacts to your actions as a manager, but also how the world of media and other NPCs in the game see you. All your choices, changes of mind, all your actions are being judged and remembered by the world. Just like in real life! Heavy breathing anyone?
He also explained how all this system was inspired and implemented also thanks to his visits to real life football clubs, observing players while training, interacting with each other and just living their lives as a football team.
Dynamics system is not just a realistic AI-improving system, it’s also and above all a very nice and powerful story generator. Just like any other strategic/managerial game, there is now a system that not-so-randomly generates events that can keep up the challenge and keep your attention high taking the replayability of the game to levels far higher than before.

Ney-mania and data analysis

One of the controversial aspects of FM18 is probably the unrealistic amount of injuries that happen during a season. It’s a side-effect of another new feature: the sport scientist.
Sport scientists are very important figures in a football club. Their role is about studying how the team is training and what are the possible consequences of training load. They also measure injury susceptibility for each player. A super duper important figure that can make the difference between your team playing with your incredibly-expensive-goleador and winning, and your team playing without him losing against my rebellious badly managed Fulham FC.
If you hire a good sport scientist and constantly listen to his suggestions, your players won’t get injured so often and so bad, but you have to be careful to not over-protect them… because often they just want to play, be trained and risk their health to score and increase their value. Again… so realistic! The fact that you can predict injuries means that injuries are not just random events, as they always were in the past, but they’re consequential to your club management. Awesome!

Another brand new feature of this 2018 iteration of Football Manager, is the introduction of the Data Analyst.
The data analyst is a staff member working in the recruitment team that is responsible of studying matches outcomes and teams behaviors. They prepare reports with graphs and statistics before and after matches highlighting to you all the key-players, their way of playing, the hot zones in the field and all the information you may want to know on both your and the opposing club. The data analyst can suggest you important information like the most probable schemes and tactics that the opposing club will probably use against you. All those invaluable data, allows you to prepare better your team for the next game and guess the right strategies to win.

This is a feature that I like and dislike at the same time.
I like it, because you’re reading data analysis about some football match that actually happened in the game… so you’re studying it like it happens in real life to improve the quality of your team.
I dislike it, because it’s a simulated match, so it’s like the interpretation of some AI-generated data and that can make it seem faux, if you fail to properly immerse in the game.

Nonetheless it’s a very impressive feature that I needed as a FM player and I’m happy it exists… but maybe it should be a bit less schematic? Maybe it would be better if it was presented as a real report with some in-depth of the clubs’ physical and mental conditions and not just a bunch of graphs and numbers. But I guess it’s not a data analyst job to collect and discuss those information?

See no evil, hear no evil

Oh my. I really love Football Manager, but guys, you have to do something for those 3D models. Why in the world people in that game have the longest arms I ever saw? Why is everyone in that game a werewolf from the first Alone In The Dark?
As you probably realized, I’m not super happy with Football Manager 2018 graphics. I understand that this is not the main focus of the team… also they’re not much into sound engineering and music. The game, after a single (just one, can you believe me?) song at the title screen, totally stops playing any kind of sound. The only sound you’re supposed to hear is the click of your mouse. Nothing more. Except when you play simulated matches… then you can hear people cheering and the ball being kicked. That’s all.
Well, at least I can chose my own soundtrack.

Concerning the UI, it’s based on FM17 with some polishing and optimization. The UI is never ambiguous or unclear. It gets you always were you want to go and gives you always the right amount of data you need. It’s very fast and comfortable to navigate through the various menu and sections. It’s probably one of the best made UI I ever saw in a management videogame. It hides a huge amount of data in a fairly compact system of tabs and windows. Kudos, SI!

I also want to highlight the optimization level of this game. FM18 is a game that manages a huge amount of data, NPCs and interactions and implements some very advanced AI algorithms and uses a 3D engine to simulate football matches, but still I could play it smoothly and without issues on a 2010 Macbook Pro using just an Intel HD 4000 graphic card. This is software optimization, guys!

Choose your game

Besides the historical Career game mode that let’s you create your football manager, chose a team and jump into the fantastic world of simulated football management, there are two game modes inherited from FM17: Fantasy Draft and Create-A-Club.

Fantasy Draft is a game mode that mocks real life fantasy football and let’s you assemble an existing team from scratch and play it against your human or AI mates in any championship. It’s made mostly for streamers, youtubers and multiplayer sessions with your friends (former LAN parties), and it’s probably the most funny and social game mode FM has ever had.

Similar to Fantasy Draft is Create-A-Club game mode, that allows you to wipe clean an existing team and substitute it with a new one made from scratch, deciding the name, the logo, the club’s stadium name, etc. It’s mostly like a mod editor for custom clubs.

As in the past, the Online modes are still available and always much fun for all those social gamers out there. Not my cup of tea, though. I don’t like social interactions as much as FM18 seems to do.

Long story short…

Football Manager 2018 is the most polished and advanced game of a series that has no rivals in sport simulation. There are a lot of similar games to FM, but no one is capable of that simulation level that only Sports Interactive can reach and overtake year by year. And no one has a database so big!
If you like football, simulations or management games, picking up FM18 is a no-brainer. It’s the best sport simulation and managment experience you can get. And with the new features, you can mess up your game with virtual 1:1 reproductions of real life prima donnas. Totally worth it!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Navigation